Evidence-gated draft: this page is noindex until the required proof is published.

Research protocol

Type vs Scan vs Draw Benchmark

This page documents the benchmark before results are published. It remains noindex so an unfinished study cannot masquerade as evidence.

Practical workflow

The process, step by step

  1. 1Use the same source material for Type, Scan, and Draw.
  2. 2Record capture time without correction.
  3. 3Count meaningful omissions and substitutions.
  4. 4Record correction time and total time to a usable note.
  5. 5Repeat across prose, headings, numbers, and a diagram.
  6. 6Publish raw observations, product versions, and limitations.

Primary measures

The benchmark will report capture time, correction time, meaningful error count, completeness, and total time to a review-ready note. It will not compress every tradeoff into one opaque score.

Fairness controls

The same device, Apple Pencil, source, lighting, and reviewer will be used. Practice runs will be separated from measured runs. Product versions and test dates will be disclosed.

Publication gate

Results, winner language, and structured research claims will be added only after raw observations and representative examples are available for inspection.

Reusable resource

Use the same process yourself

The download is versioned and links back to this canonical page so tests can be repeated and cited.

Download the test sheet used by the protocol
Editorial trust

Sources, method, and update policy

Product claims are checked against the current app. Competitor claims use dated official sources. Corrections can be sent to alpaca-labs.dev@proton.me.

Keep going

guide

Type vs Scan vs Draw Notes: Which Input Mode Should You Use?

Compare typing, scanning paper, and Apple Pencil handwriting by speed, structure, review effort, and study use.

Read guide

resource

Handwriting Recognition Test Sheet

A printable set of headings, prose, numbers, symbols, and subject terms for comparing handwriting recognition apps.

Read resource

feature

Apple Pencil Note-Taking App for Handwritten Notes

Handwrite notes on iPad with Apple Pencil, then review, recognize, organize, study, or export them in Pocket Orbit.

Read feature

Try the Type, Scan, and Draw workflow

Download Pocket Orbit from the App Store, then use the linked help articles to test it with your own notes.

Download Pocket Orbit on the App Store